Jump to Navigation

The Duty to Defend

A local family owned four properties in Massachusetts.  Three homeowners' insurance policies insured three of the properties, but did not insure a fourth residential property.  The policies insured family members against bodily injury claims, but each policy also contained an "uninsured location" (UL) exclusion disclaiming coverage for injuries "arising out of a premises" owned by an insured but not itself an "insured location."  Misfortune occurred during the use of a portable fire pit at the fourth property and the injured parties sued one of the owners in state court.

The insurance company filed a separate action in federal court seeking a declaration that it was not obliged to defend the property owner because of the UL exclusion.  Applying Massachusetts law, the 1st Circuit Court of Appeals decided that the insurer indeed had a duty to defend the owner because the portable fire pit was not a "condition of the premises" and thus did not "arise out of" the premises as as articulated in the UL exclusion provision.  The court's decision reinforced the long-held and expansive principle that ambiguity in insurance contract provisions will be construed against the insurer.

Interpreting insurance contracts and the applicable law is no simple matter.  If you need counsel in order to protect your rights under an insurance policy, contact the experienced lawyers at Harris & Asscoiates, P.C.  

No Comments

Leave a comment
Comment Information
FindLaw Network
Need Legal Assistance?

Contact us to discuss your insurance claim dispute or tort litigation matter with one of our lawyers today.

Bold labels are required.

Contact Information

The use of the Internet or this form for communication with the firm or any individual member of the firm does not establish an attorney-client relationship. Confidential or time-sensitive information should not be sent through this form.


Privacy Policy

Subscribe to this blog's feed
Office Location

Harris & Associates, P.C
15 Broad Street, Suite 701
Boston MA 02109

Telephone: 617-523-1100
Telephone: 617-275-2226
Fax: 617-523-2060

  • Avvo Rating 100 Superb Top Attorney Personal Injury
  • Massachusetts Bar Association
  • Peer Review Rated